The 3-8 Jets: How it all went so wrong so fast for Aaron Rodgers & Co.
Aaron Rodgers made a couple of statements last spring that ended up being more accurate than any pass he’s thrown in a Jets uniform.
“There’s a lot of heat on all of us,” he said. “If I don’t do what I know I’m capable of doing, we’re all probably going to be out of here.”
Rodgers was on target.
Owner Woody Johnson fired coach Robert Saleh on Oct. 8 and dismissed general manager Joe Douglas on Tuesday. Rodgers’ time with the Jets likely is nearing an end, too.
The Jets are 3-8 at their bye with a housecleaning in full effect. Here’s a look at how and why this season has unraveled:
Woody’s world
The best owners hire good people and trust them to do their jobs without getting too involved. Johnson doesn’t fit that description.
Last season, management wanted a proven veteran backup behind Rodgers but were not allowed to sign one because of the money invested in Zach Wilson.
This year, firing Saleh after five games was a flat-out bad move that the impulsive Johnson orchestrated without any input. At that point, Douglas became a GM in title only.
There are reports that Johnson wanted Rodgers benched after Week 4 with the Jets 2-2. That’s troubling, to say the least. Johnson also had his hands in acquiring Davante Adams and ending Haason Reddick’s holdout.
Johnson reportedly blocked Douglas from extending edge rusher Bryce Huff’s contract. Huff signed with Philadelphia in free agency.
Many factors go into a team missing the playoffs for 13 consecutive years — soon to be 14 — but it usually starts at the top.
Rodgers’ regression
Rodgers is not the same quarterback he once was. The mobility is gone. He’s not throwing the ball down the field. He’s missing receivers often. Age and last year’s Achilles tear have taken its toll on Rodgers, who will be 41 in less than two weeks.
A major Jets error, though, was believing that Rodgers could cover for whatever issues they had, from protection to coaching to play-calling. Maybe a young, healthy Rodgers could have, but not this version.
If anything, Rodgers should have been benched after the loss to Minnesota in London when he threw three interceptions and was bent in half. The Jets should have given him a couple of weeks to get right. Instead, Saleh was fired.
Moreover, the Jets gave Rodgers too much power from the beginning. They hired his favorite coach (Nathaniel Hackett) and signed two close friends (Allen Lazard and Randall Cobb) last season. The Packers 2.0 failed miserably.
Things might have gone differently if Rodgers hadn’t gotten hurt and was the Rodgers of old instead of an old Rodgers.
Roster mismanagement
Johnson’s meddling notwithstanding, roster building falls on Douglas. There were clear mistakes and miscalculations.
The Reddick situation was one for sure. Douglas never should have traded for Reddick without a new contract in place. He held out until Oct. 21.
Reddick’s acquisition led to the Jets trading important player and locker room presence John Franklin-Myers. Losing Huff, Franklin-Myers and Quinton Jefferson from last year’s line weakened the defense, especially with Reddick refusing to show up.
It got worse in Week 2. Jermaine Johnson tore an Achilles tendon, leaving Will McDonald and Micheal Clemons as the starting edge rushers. They were going to be in the D-line rotation but not play such big roles.
Sticking with Greg Zuerlein over Austin Seibert, who was the better kicker in camp and the preseason, proved costly.
Seibert has made 92.6% of his field-goal attempts and all of his extra-point tries with Washington. Zuerlein missed a potential game-winning field goal in a one-point loss to Denver, missed two more in a three-point loss to Buffalo and missed a field goal and extra point in a three-point loss to New England. The Jets have had four different kickers in the last four games.
Coaching matters
The Jets have underachieved. Saleh is a great defensive coach but not a head coach. Still, he should have been allowed to finish the season. The defense hasn’t been the same since Saleh was let go.
Interim coach Jeff Ulbrich was thrust into a role he’s never had — having to oversee the entire team and still run the defense as the coordinator. It’s been a mess.
The Jets were No. 2 in total defense and fifth in points allowed through the first five games. They’re 27th in total defense and 24th in scoring defense in the last six games. They allowed last-minute game-winning touchdown drives in two of the last four games.
Injured linebacker and captain C.J. Mosley and his ability to call and change the defense based on what he’s seeing have been missed. Hiring Hackett as offensive coordinator — the precursor to getting Rodgers — was a major misstep by Saleh and the Jets. Saleh recognized that after last year and tried to hire someone (Arthur Smith, Kliff Kingsbury, among others) to be the de facto offensive coordinator over Hackett, just without the title. They couldn’t fire Hackett — Rodgers loves him — but Hackett was stripped of his play-calling duties after Week 5. The Jets averaged 18.6 points under Hackett and are scoring 18.5 points under his replacement, Todd Downing.
It turns out Johnson was way off when he said quarterback was “the missing piece” before acquiring Rodgers. They need much more than that, starting with a complete culture change.