Health insurance costs to jump in 2027 on Long Island
Matthew A. Caselli, president of Eagle Group Planning Inc. in Melville, said companies often are choosing plans with higher deductibles and employee copays. Credit: Newsday/Alejandra Villa Loarca
Many Long Island employees and business owners will pay significantly more for health insurance next year, as prices for treatments and medications continue to rise and companies choose plans that require workers to shoulder more healthcare costs.
Employers nationwide are expecting the biggest increase in healthcare expenses since 2003 — 8.2% — according to a survey of businesses with 50 or more employees by the Manhattan-based consulting firm Marsh. That increase would have been 11% if companies hadn’t found ways to reduce expenses.
Many businesses that previously had been reluctant to pass on the full cost of annual insurance premium increases to workers are now doing so, said Beth Umland, director of health research for Marsh.
Some companies are trimming the share of premium costs they cover — for example, reducing the 80% of employees’ premiums, a common percentage, to a lower proportion in 2027, Umland said.
WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND
- Many Long Island businesses and employees will pay significantly more for healthcare in 2027. Expensive treatments and medications and healthcare system consolidation are among the reasons, experts said.
- Nationwide, costs are projected to rise 8.2%, the highest amount since 2003, and that’s after companies’ cost-cutting measures, a survey found.
- In addition to increased premiums, many policyholders will face higher deductibles and copays, and reduced coverage.
"Their hand has sort of been forced with trends of this size," she said.
Costs for Affordable Care Act plans are rising even more, a median of 13% for mid-level plans, as are prices for Medicare Part D premiums, which cover prescription drugs and are expected to spike by an average of 50%, assuming that policyholders keep their current plans, according to analyses by the health research and policy nonprofit KFF.
Premiums for small-business plans that Melville insurance agent Matthew Caselli handles are increasing by an average of about 4% to 6%. But, he said, some insurers have dropped low-premium plans, forcing businesses to choose from more expensive options.
"I’ve seen increases of up to 60%" after businesses' low-premium policies were excised, said Caselli, president of Eagle Group Planning. "Products are being streamlined, and they’re eliminating less profitable plans."
Difficult choices
Companies often are choosing plans with higher deductibles and employee copays, Caselli said. More businesses also are buying "non-traditional products," such as ones that allow small companies to pool together to form a larger insurance plan, he said.
That is what Chris Dara, a client of Caselli and owner of IT in Demand in Huntington, an IT support company with five employees, plans to do in 2027.
Buying a traditional group insurance plan "is unattainable," Dara said.
The Affordable Care Act requires companies of 50 or more employees to provide health insurance or face a penalty. Smaller businesses are exempt. Only about 23% of businesses with fewer than 10 employees, and 52% of those with 10-24 employees, offer health coverage, according to 2023 data analyzed by the Washington, D.C.-based Employee Benefits Research Institute.
Waxman & Bland, a Melville accounting firm, provides coverage for its six employees despite the cost and lack of legal requirement in part because "we’re competing for employees against some incredibly large accounting firms that have a more robust benefit package than we do," said Frank Bland, managing partner of the company. Some pay 100% of the cost of premiums, he said.
"We just can’t do that," so his firm offers flexibility in time off and work schedules to help compete, he said.
The state caps rate increases for plans that it regulates. State-regulated small-group plans for businesses with 100 or fewer employees will increase an average 8% in 2027, with the amount varying by company, and individual plans will increase an average of 6%, according to the Department of Financial Services, which approved the price hikes. Both figures are much less than insurers had requested, the state said.
Increases in healthcare costs have long outpaced the overall inflation rate: Between 2000 and 2024, medical spending rose more than 121%, compared with an 86% increase in the price of goods and services overall, according to a KFF analysis of federal data.
"It’s difficult to say what turns the tide," said Sunit Patel, chief actuary for Marsh U.S. Health.
One potential way to control costs in the future is efficiencies from increased use of artificial intelligence, Patel said. In addition, he said, some medications, such as GLP-1 weight-loss drugs, may reduce healthcare costs over time, especially if the price of the medications continues to fall, because the savings yielded by the health benefits of the drugs may outweigh their costs.
Weight-loss drugs
The continued popularity of GLP-1s is a key factor in the 2027 increase in health costs, he said. Some employers have stopped covering GLP-1s other than for diabetes, or they’re requiring that those who take the medications participate in coaching programs designed to increase effectiveness, Umland said.
Other pricey medications and very expensive new treatments — some gene therapies cost millions of dollars — also are contributing to rising costs, Patel said.
Consolidation of healthcare systems, which increases their bargaining power with insurers, is another factor, Umland and Patel found in their Marsh analysis. On Long Island, there no longer is an independent hospital other than the public Nassau University Medical Center, and a rising number of outpatient practices now affiliate with large health systems.
The same factors pushing up healthcare costs overall are increasing the prices of ACA plans, said Matt McGough, a policy analyst in KFF’s ACA program.
Another key reason is the Republican-controlled Congress’ decision to reduce or eliminate tax credits in 2026 for ACA policies for many middle and upper middle income families. Democrats have vowed to restore the subsidies when they assume the majority in January, but President Donald Trump, who supported reduced subsidies, could veto any legislation.
People with lower incomes who make too much to qualify for Medicaid still receive large tax credits. But many who lost subsidies, or who now only qualify for much smaller ones, saw huge increases in premiums, leading many younger, healthier people to forgo insurance, McGough said. Older, sicker people are more likely to maintain coverage, he said.
The result is that a higher percentage of people in these ACA plans have health problems and high medical expenses. McGough said insurers are "going to increase premiums to compensate for that."
Sag Harbor eyes limiting chain stores ... Latest on national ground stop ... LI weather forecast ... Out East: 1760 Homestead Farm
Sag Harbor eyes limiting chain stores ... Latest on national ground stop ... LI weather forecast ... Out East: 1760 Homestead Farm



