Editorial: Jacobs in Nassau 16th District

James Milano, 44, a promising Republican physician from Oyster Bay, has given himself a difficult challenge in taking on Judy Jacobs, 72, of Woodbury, who is an original, 16-year member of the legislature, a former Democratic presiding officer and a continual firebrand.

Both candidates like the idea of the Islanders moving to create an entertainment locale near Belmont Racetrack, although Jacobs believes it's a long shot. Milano supports the idea of shrinking eight police precincts into six. Jacobs thinks the precinct consolidation would save too little money for the sense of security that people would give up. She favors additional red-light cameras to raise revenue.

Milano is likable and smart, and he belongs in public service. But Jacobs is an invaluable leader and source of institutional knowledge. Newsday endorses Jacobs.