$10.75M Montauk home has tackle room, wine cellar, Fort Pond Bay views

A Montauk home with a fishing tackle room and wine cellar is on the market for $10.75 million.

The home has five bedrooms, 7½ bathrooms, a gym and bay views. Annual taxes on the property, which falls within the Montauk Public School district, total $29,478.

"It’s just breathtaking," said Douglas Elliman agent Kate Plachy of the views of Fort Pond Bay, visible from the kitchen. "It’s just so calming and beautiful."

Built in 2008 on a 1.66-acre lot, the light gray-shingled house has two levels and the basement wine cellar. The house is warmed by propane, forced air and radiant heat, and cooled by central air conditioning.

Beyond a staircase and through a red-brick passageway, a cast-iron gate leads to a dine-in wine cellar.

"It totally transports you to a different world," said Plachy, who has co-listed the property with Katherine Casey and Miles Bouckoms. "It’s such a moment, to experience walking in there and just having a glass of wine at that table."

Stone and wooden details promote a neutral color scheme and a nautical quality. In the tackle room, wood-paneled walls wear racks for fishing poles; a mural depicts fluffy clouds, flying seagulls and frothy waters.

"When you’re in the house, you can just feel that a family lived there and loved this home, and that they built it to bring people in and make people feel at home in their home, and enjoy themselves," Plachy said.

More photos inside the Montauk home

By Arielle Dollinger

arielle.dollinger@newsday.com@aridollinger

Arielle Dollinger joined Newsday as a staff reporter in 2022. Previously, she covered local and national news as a freelancer for The New York Times, Newsday and other outlets.