Aston Villa gives away bizarre penalty for handball to gift Club Brugge the win in Champions League
Brugge's Hans Vanaken, left, celebrates with teammates after scoring a penalty his side's first goal, during the Champions League opening phase soccer match between Club Brugge and Aston Villa at Jan Breydelstadion in Bruges, Belgium, Wednesday, Nov. 6, 2024. Credit: AP/Geert Vanden Wijngaert
BRUGGE, Belgium — Aston Villa's winning run in the Champions League ended after a bizarre penalty incident Wednesday that coach Unai Emery described as the “biggest mistake” he's ever seen in his career.
The mental lapse by defender Tyrone Mings, who conceded a spot kick by picking up the ball with his hand after a short goal kick by goalkeeper Emiliano Martínez, gifted Club Brugge a 1-0 win.
Villa had won its first three games without conceding a single goal in the club's first appearance in the elite competition since it was the defending champion 41 years ago.
“His mistake is completely strange. It’s the biggest mistake I witnessed in my career,” Emery said. "It has only happened one time in all my life. Today.”
A similar incident did happen already in the Champions League last season — but a penalty kick was not given that time.
In the quarterfinals, Arsenal defender Gabriel went unpunished for picking up a short pass from goalkeeper David Raya in the first leg against Bayern Munich.
Bayern’s then-coach Thomas Tuchel later criticized the referee who had said he would not award a penalty for a “kid’s mistake.”
Aston Villa's head coach Unai Emery watches the Champions League opening phase soccer match between Club Brugge and Aston Villa at Jan Breydelstadion in Bruges, Belgium, Wednesday, Nov. 6, 2024. Credit: AP/Geert Vanden Wijngaert
A difference in the Villa incident was that the ball went forward out of the six-yard box with Martínez seeming to have intentionally restarted play early in the second half.
Mings apparently thought the ball was not yet in play. He walked forward to pick it up with his left hand and returned it to place it at the corner of the six-yard box.
Brugge captain Hans Vanaken converted the penalty in the 52nd minute to give Brugge a 1-0 lead, placing the ball to Martínez's left as the World Cup-winning Argentina goalkeeper dived to his right.
Martínez tried to persuade German referee Tobias Stieler after the game that he had made a mistake.
Brugge's Bjorn Meijer, left, and Aston Villa's Boubacar Kamara jump for the ball during the Champions League opening phase soccer match between Club Brugge and Aston Villa at Jan Breydelstadion in Bruges, Belgium, Wednesday, Nov. 6, 2024. Credit: AP/Geert Vanden Wijngaert
VIlla defender Ezri Konsa suggested the referee compounded his mistakes because Mings had previously been shown a yellow card in the first half.
“He’s on a yellow already, so why not send him off for that?” Konsa told British broadcaster TNT in a post-game interview.
Villa had been the surprise leader in the 36-team standings and provisionally dropped to fifth before hosting Juventus in three weeks' time.
Brugge has six points from two wins and two losses, and was in 20th place. After all eight rounds in January that would earn a place in the knockout playoffs round.
More soccer news
