Haley Reinhart kind of a hot mess on 'American Idol'

Haley Reinhart is singing "Call Me" on "American Idol." It's a totally unusual song that I think will really fit her interesting voice. Whoa, holy minidress and thigh highs....

She's totally feeling it. I think Simon would've called this self-indulgent, but it's not really something you can stop watching. Her voice is a bit weak in parts, and it all kind of has a frenetic, half-finished feel so I'm not thrilled about it. But at least it wasn't same old. However, the more it goes on, the more of a hot mess it seems.

Randy Jackson didn't like the start, calls it karaoke. He tells her it "wasn't really a showcase for your voice for me." Hmm, this could be it for her . . .