<p>
	Newsday food critic Scott Vogel tries Long Island&#39;s most over-the-top lobster roll, an $85 triple-meat affair at Claws Seafood Market in West Sayville.
</p>


Things to Do

FeedMe

FDCLAW220624_video

Scott Vogel tries Long Island's most expensive lobster roll at Claws Seafood Market in West Sayville

West Sayville

onecms:09e4f32e-aecf-447a-ba13-15bca62b85a3

Newsday

Food critic tries $85 lobster roll

FDLOBSTER220601_photos

Get the Feed Me newsletter. We know the best places to eat on LI.

Feed Me newsletter sign up widget

The Baldwin fixture will close April 10, the owner said.

LI diner closing after 61 years

Most Popular

Lifestyle Rail Module

Prepare to have your mind blown by hundreds of flavors in mind-boggling combos.

Spice-and-tea specialty shop opens new LI location

The owner confirmed the closing of the restaurant that opened in 2021, but was unable to give any more details due to a pending sale with an unnamed local business.

Top LI steakhouse closes 

There's no other dining scene in Suffolk that rivals this one.

The best places to eat in Huntington

Find out which local eateries recently served their last meals.

Biggest LI restaurant closings of the year so far

Check out Long Island's latest restaurant openings.

New Long Island restaurants to try in 2025

The Manhattan-based international chain, known for its crinkle-cut fries, milkshakes and burgers has expanded quickly across the country and Long Island.

Shake Shack to open 5 new locations on LI by 2026

Things to Do Article Bottom Module

It still serves breakfast, lunch and dinner, but with more style

All-day family eatery replaces LI diner

Explore our critics' picks for all of your favorite foods on the Island.

Dig in: The best FeedMe restaurant guides 

No matter where you are on Long Island, you're never far from homemade ice cream. 

LI's best homemade ice cream

Billing itself as a "new kind of food hall," it offers popular dishes from 18 restaurants in one place.

New LI takeout spot offers dishes from 18 restaurants

The takeout-only shop specializes in Colombian empanadas.

NYC empanada specialist opens in Farmingdale

Enter ice cream nachos and fat ice cream sandwiches with inventive flavors.

LI couple opens new ice cream shop

Things to Do Video Playlist

The beach was swarmed with visitors on Sunday, a state parks official said.

Memorial Day Air Show 2025 at Jones Beach

NewsdayTV's Elisa DiStefano and Newsday food writer Marie Elena Martinez check out Mill Pond Steak & Seafood in Centerport, which has recently been renovated. 

Waterside dining in Centerport

From new rides at Adventureland and Splish Splash to Long Island's best gelato to must-see summer concerts, NewsdayTV's Elisa DiStefano has your inside look at Newsday's summer FunBook.

Your guide to excitement under the sun!

Newsday food writer Marie Elena Martinez visits Levittown Food Trucks - TGIF, which is hosted by Good Shepherd Lutheran Church in Levittown. 

'It's just a place to get together every Friday night'

NewsdayTV's Elisa DiStefano talked to the NY State Parks regional director about the upcoming FourLeaf Air Show at Jones Beach May 24-25.

Know before you go: FourLeaf Air Show at Jones Beach

As Circle M Diner in Wantagh prepares to celebrate its 50th anniversary on Wednesday, co-owner John Tsotsos attributes its success to good food and loyal customers. 

'They come back with their own little babies'

For more than three decades, Rob Rimmer, the chief brand officer at Lacrosse Unlimited in Edgewood, has been pouring his heart into making custom sticks. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa reports.

'It's all about expressing yourself on the field'

NewsdayTV's Elisa DiStefano tries brioche con gelato at Spiga Bakery in Bellmore.

'We actually started this dessert 18 years ago'

Newsday food writer Melissa Azofeifa tries the Dubai cheesecake at The Dirty Cheesecake in Smithtown.

'You get the creaminess with the crunch'

Two Mom Crews is a group created for families with two moms to bond with other moms raising young children and make new friends. Newsday family reporter Beth Whitehouse was at the group's inaugural event in Babylon.

  Playdate unites families with two moms

NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa heads to North Quarter Farm and Tweeds in Riverhead.

'It's a wonderful experience'

Newsday food writer Erica Marcus visits Gra-Bar in Copiague to learn about local versus non-local fish.

Exploring fish at Gra-Bar in Copiague

FeedMe Vertical videos

A single bite of its shatteringly crisp, golden-brown fabulousness will make an instant taste memory.

Crunch time: Where to find the best Korean fried chicken on LI 

The social media sensation is popping up in elaborate desserts and simple milkshakes.

Places to try trendy Dubai chocolate on LI

The festive thin-crust pizza specialist counts supermodel Heidi Klum as a partner at its NYC location.

Over-the-top NYC pizza spot opening LI location

The Mineola taco spot is expanding to Baldwin, setting up in a former Friendly's.

 Inside LI taco spot's second location

The ambitious kaiseki tasting menu is 10 courses.

Longtime Long Island restaurant turns into upscale Japanese spot

Alibi Lounge in Farmingdale is being transformed into a sweet destination.

Candy-themed popup opens in Farmingdale

Customers are warned against ordering anything hotter than a medium.

A look inside Long Island's first Dave's Hot Chicken

It was retirement in 2020 that pushed Randolph Brown toward fulfilling a lifelong dream: opening his own BBQ restaurant. 

'I had a fascination with preparing meals'

NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa visits three Long Island restaurants to find out where the best wings are.

LI's best chicken wings? We've got the sauce!

NewsdayTV's Andi Berlin tries the Flying Dutchman burger at 8-Bit Bites in Centereach. 

Centereach's 8-Bit Bites serves up popular burger with a side of fun

FeedMe Trending Articles

FeedMe Magazine

Find your waterside table with our searchable guide to restaurants on the north and south shores.

Best restaurants on the water

Here are 12 shops making their own creamy flavors in house.

Top gelato spots on LI

FeedMe - megaslot

feed-me-142x30

The best Long Island restaurants, from Italian to Chinese, plus dining out reviews of best pizza, tacos and more.

Top Videos

Stay logged in.