Manorhaven Pool redone, but not all happy

Nearly eight weeks into the summer recreation season after a $12-million renovation, Manorhaven Pool in North Hempstead Town has seen membership increase by nearly 250 percent.

Gone is the T-shaped pool and diving area built in 1963 that was showing its age.

In its place is a family-friendly recreation center with two slides, a 23,000-square-foot main pool and another 2,500-square-foot pool.

Town officials call it a huge success and point to resident-only membership that increased from 1,278 in 2010 to 4,443 so far this year.

But critics say the clover-shaped pool is too shallow, not sufficiently shaded and suffering from poor drainage in the bathhouse. And, they say, it's not ideal for swim teams.

"We get glowing comments," said Supervisor Jon Kaiman, who calls the criticism politically motivated. "There's a few people who don't like change."

The new pool averages 31/2 feet deep with a nearly 5-foot depth in lap lanes, according to facility director Kevin Hawkins. Instead of steps, it has a more accessible ramp-like entry.

The pool "appeals more to families now," he said.

But some members find it too shallow.

"The pool is aesthetically nice but there's not enough water to swim," said Bud Green, a Port Washington resident.

A landscaped island sits in the center of the pool. Fountains are spread around and two slides occupy one leaf of the clover. Lawn chairs and shade cabanas surround the pool and a deck offers unobstructed views of Manhasset Bay. More shade covers are on order, Hawkins said.

"It's just so beautiful, you feel like you're in an island oasis," said Jennifer Scotto-Robinson, who was at the pool recently with her twins, 21/2, her husband and mother, who was one of the first guests of the original Manorhaven pool.

"It's different now," said Maureen Scotto-Ferrante of Port Washington. "Now it's convenient for the children."

In addition to leisure guests, the Division 1 Manorhaven Red Devils, a Port Washington swim team for ages 5-16, practices at the pool and occasionally hosts swim meets there. But starting blocks aren't installed and spectators have few places to sit and watch, said Soundview resident Laurie Passauer.

"It's beautiful to look at, but that's all it is," she said. "A lot of people are disappointed."

Kaiman counters that the pool was never meant for competitive use.

Town officials say getting the first season completed provides an opportunity to evaluate issues and make changes where necessary.

Once the pool closes after Labor Day, a contractor will correct the puddling issue in the renovated bath house, Hawkins said.

Engineers will also look at the pool's depth to see if anything can or should be done, town spokesman Collin Nash said.