Twenty years on, Tellers in Islip continues to be one of the Island's top meat palaces.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

The Celebration steak, a bone-in NY strip, is glazed with bourbon cherry compote at Tellers in Islip.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

Tellers in Islip occupies an expanded version of what was once a bank.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

Diners in the lofty space at Tellers in Islip. 

Credit: Daniel Brennan

The bar at Tellers in Islip features warm golden tones and a high vaulted ceiling with additional dining next to a fire place.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

What was once the bank vault now houses the top shelf wines at Tellers in Islip.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

Tuna Rossini, planks of rosy-hued fish arranged tepee-style over foie gras and black truffle sauce, is served at Tellers in Islip.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

Black pepper bacon, which is actually an inch-thick slab of pork belly with a tongue-tingling horseradish glaze and inky sear, is served at Tellers in Islip.

Credit: Daniel Brennan

The superb Key lime pie is scrumptious on its own, but sublime when plated with a blueberry sauce and coconut sorbet at Tellers in Islip.

 
SUBSCRIBE

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

ACT NOWSALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME